I tried Seesmic Desktop alongside of TweetDeck for a short period of time and it didn’t take long for me to realize that Seesmic Desktop and TweetDeck are shadows of each other. If you look at the two clients side-by-side, you can barely tell the difference. Seesmic looks a lot like TweetDeck and has most of the same features. Each client also has features the other lacks, which makes it very hard to chose between them. Even as I write this review, I find myself once again waffling between the two clients. Sometimes, TweetDeck works better for me, but at other times, Seesmic is the better fit.
These are some of the features Seesmic Desktop has in common with TweetDeck:
- Handles multiple Twitter accounts.
- Support for multiple URL shortening services.
- In program profile viewer with the ability to follow, unfollow, and block.
- Support for saved searches.
- Support for unlimited columns.
- Support for posting a single message to multiple accounts.
- Single column view mode.
These are the features Seesmic Desktop lacks:
- The ability to view images within the program itself rather than opening via the browser.
- Support for trending topics and tag clouds via TwitScoop.
- Support for groups
- Support for scheduled tweets.
- Short URL Previews.
- No support for MySpace, Foursquare, or LinkedIn.
- No support for global filtering.
- Ability to change the programs color scheme.
Here are some of the features that Seesmic Desktop has in its favor:
- Handy navigation bar on the left, which can be expanded or collapsed as needed.
- Option to control the width of the columns. (I LOVE this feature.)
- The “Home” column which combines tweets from all accounts into a single column, a nice feature if you like it, can be closed if you don’t.
- Support for a larger number of URL shortening services than TweetDeck.
- Much less annoying notification sound than TweetDeck. Still no support for changing the notification sound though.
- Better font than TweetDeck.
The good news is that Seesmic Desktop is fairly new and still in the development process, so there is always the possibility that, if they implement the missing TweetDeck features and continue to add features that TweetDeck lacks, it could very well end up being a much better client than TweetDeck. It’s too early to tell, but I will definitely be keeping an eye on both in the future.
I’d love to hear your opinion. Which client do you like better and why?
Of all the Twitter clients I tried, Digsy was the one that almost stole me away from using TweetDeck, which is surprising considering Digsby was the most lacking in features of all the clients I tried. I used Digsby for several months before making the switch to TweetDeck and still alternated back and forth between the two for while after that. Even now, there are days when I’m tempted to use Digsby just to get a break from the annoying TweetDeck chirp.
Here are a few of the benefits of using Digsby:
- Handles multiple accounts for Twitter, Facebook, MySpace and LinkedIn
- Ability to open separate columns for each account, resize them, and move them to any position on the screen.
- Completely customizable appearance with skins.
- Ability to customize the notification sounds (big, big, BIG plus for me).
- Can be used for instant messaging and email as well as for managing social network accounts
- Less memory usage than TweetDeck
Unfortunately, as much as I loved the ability to customize the look and feel of Digsby, there were too many features I needed that it just didn’t have and ultimately those missing features drove me to TweetDeck. Here are some of the features Digsby didn’t offer:
- No ability to create saved searches in columns so I could monitor subjects that are of interest to me.
- No way to save the position and sizes of the columns for each account when opened and positioned on the screen. Each time I started the program, I would have to reopen the columns, re-size them and reposition them on the screen again.
- Each column opened took up space on my taskbar.
- Not able to view, follow, or unfollow Twitter profiles without going to the Twitter website and logging into one of the accounts.
- No ability to handle images or video within Digsby.
- No ability to post messages to multiple accounts at the same time.
I think the part of Digsby that most impressed me was the customization features. I love being able to customize the look and sound of my software to match my personality. With Digsby, you can do that. With TweetDeck, you can’t.
I hope the developers of TweetDeck are listening and will someday add more customization options to their software. If they do that, they will be almost unbeatable as a Social Networking client. For TweetDeck competitors, here’s your chance. If you can have all the features of TweetDeck AND add the ability to customize font size, column size and positioning within the program screen, colors and notification sounds, you’ll knock TweetDeck out of the park.
Twhirl is one of the Twitter clients I tried when I finally became fed up with logging in and out of Twitter and Facebook to manage my multiple accounts. Twhirl has some very nice features and for people who need a simple client to manage a few Twitter accounts, it is an excellent choice. Here are some of the best features
- Connects to multiple Twitter accounts.
- Notification display and sound for new messages.
- Support for bit.ly URL shortening.
- Twitter search with saved searches.
- Option to change the font size of the time line.
- Single column display.
In spite of its many wonderful features, however, it didn’t take long for me to realize that Twhirl was not the right client for me. In a side-by-side comparison with TweetDeck, Twhirl doesn’t measure up.
- Twhirl: No facebook support.
- TweetDeck: Complete integration with Facebook, including the ability to record 12 seconds of video and post to a facebook account.
- Twhirl: Can create and activate a dynamic search but lacks filtering capability.
- TweetDeck: Can create detailed, saved searches using filter options. Also integrates with TwitScoop.
URL Shortening Service:
- Twhirl: Automatically posts TinyURL.
- TweetDeck: Able to use one of 5 major URL shortening services, including bit.ly, my service of choice. Also has a shortened URL preview option, so I can see where a link is going before I click on it.
- Twhirl: Does not have the ability to create custom groups.
- TweetDeck: Users can create custom groups and lists to group content together in meaningful ways, so you don’t miss those important tweets that would otherwise get lost in the crowd.
In addition to these major feature differences, I found the overall look, feel, and user experience of TweetDeck to be better than Twhirl. I like the multi-column layout that allows me to see several accounts at a glance and I like how easy it is to post tweets over multiple accounts, view profiles, follow and unfollow other users, and a host of other simple things that are just so much easier in TweetDeck.
There is only one feature of Twhirl that I wish TweetDeck would implement. That is the ability to change the font size in the time lines. If TweetDeck could do that AND give users the option to change that annoying chirp notification sound to something more pleasing, it would be perfect for me. Got that TweetDeck?
I’m interested in hearing from users of both TweetDeck and Twhirl. Leave a comment and tell me your experiences. Why do you prefer one over the other?
Do you have multiple Twitter accounts? How about a Facebook account or two? MySpace? LinkedIn? Foursquare?
If you’re like me, you probably have multiple accounts at several of these sites and keeping up with them can easily become overwhelming. In the past few weeks I’ve tested several different options for managing those accounts without logging in and out of each one on a daily basis. Here are just a few of the options I’ve tried:
- Seesmic Desktop
- and, of course, TweetDeck
I am primarily a Twitter user, but do have accounts on some of the other sites and after much tinkering and testing under my normal usage patterns, TweetDeck has emerged the winner. Although there are a few things about TweetDeck I would change if I could (annoying chirp notification anyone?), overall, the features have worked out well for me and allowed me to do everything I need to do in the most simple and organized way. The following features were the most important to me:
- The ability to update multiple accounts on multiple sites with a single update.
- The ability to manage twitter retweets, replies, follows, unfollows, & direct messages directly from TweetDeck.
- The ability to view YouTube videos, images from multiple image services, and twitter profiles directly from TweetDeck
- The ability to create and save searches, allowing me to monitor subjects that are of interest to me.
- The ability to schedule posts for a future date.
- The ability to filter out unwanted posts or data using the global filter.
- The ability to preview short URLs to know where the link goes before I click on it.
- The ability to control and eliminate most Twitter spam.
There are many more features that I enjoy and will probably find myself using more and more as I continue to learn about TweetDeck.
If you’re interested in knowing why I chose TweetDeck over some of the other options I tried, be sure and check back over the next few weeks. I will be posting comparisons between TweetDeck and each of the other options I tried, along with my reasons for ruling them out.
If you know of any other options I should try, please post a comment and tell me about them. I’m always open to trying new things. I’d also love to hear about what works for you. How do you keep up with your accounts?
Related articles by Zemanta:
Reading blogs on the internet is a lot like panning for gold. You have to sift through a lot of grit and sand to find the good stuff. If you don’t give up, you’ll find a lot of gold flakes that make the search worthwhile. Every once in a while, you get lucky and find a gold nugget.
Blogging Without A Blog is one of those gold nuggets.
The blog is written by Barbara Swafford. She describes herself as a wife, mother and grandmother who created the blog as a place to record the lessons she’s learned from blogging. In the process, she has built so much more. She has created a community of wonderful people who come there, not only to learn from Barbara, but to share their own thoughts and lives as well.
Although I recognize the WordPress theme used for the design, it is a perfect fit for her site. It flows well and is laid out to make it easy to find whatever you are searching for. Anything not found on the front page can be found by using the search bar on the pen in the upper right corner or via the links along the top of the page.
Best of all is the content. Barbara’s posts are both informative and thought-provoking. They are well written and posted often enough to keep you coming back for more yet far enough apart to give you time to think about and respond to each one. The “assignments” at the end of each post encourage her readers to do just that. I have yet to find a post that wasn’t followed by a lively discussion between Barbara and her followers, all of them insightful and informative on their own. It is obvious that Barbara cares about each of the visitors to her blog.
I was somewhat disappointed to find it no longer possible to post your blog to her blog registry, since the comments section for posting has been closed. But in the end, it doesn’t really matter. I’ve found just as many wonderful blogs from links in the comments as I would have by looking in the directory, maybe even more so. Reading the comments allows me to see the writer’s personality, peaking my curiosity, much more than a simple directory listing would.
Thanks to Barbara’s wonderful site, I’ve found many wonderful blogs to read. Now if I can only find the time to read them all!